Home Fame Games Charts Artists & Songs Read This Q&A Links Sign Up Log In Search
FG FORUM!
Loading FG update... Effigy Awards

FAME GAMES REVIEWERS
Here's a list of the reviewers registered so far, many of whom have contributed their reviews to the current Qualification rounds of Fame Games. Read rules HERE.

Listing clarifications:

Types:
(for Listener, Peer and Expert)

Levels:
"Level 1" is when the reviewer is new to us and not yet well tested. "Level 2" is when we have reasons to accord extra respect to the reviewer. "Level 3" is reserved for reviewers who not only meet the "level 2" criteria, but also have reviewed 100 or more times - and - have received high level of approval from either ourselves or the artists they have reviewed. Level rankings do not apply to expert reviewers.

Characters:
We accord a "character" to each reviewer based on our observations and listener feedback. Character can change any time. You can also suggest a character for yourself, if you´re a reviewer!
- cool dude (default) - sexy girl (default - for girls!) - mischevious - supportive (more coming up...!)

12review (USA) - Age: 41 (M). Approved since 21-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "N/A".
What makes a hit: "N/A".
Favourite Genre: dance, pop , country.
Favorite artists: ??????.
Hero: me.
Reviews to date: 2

32CC (Australia) - Age: 33 (M). Approved since 04-Jun-07
View reviews
Criteria: "Lyrics....a story that resonates with me. Catchy riffs that have an original sound.....music that doesn`t sound like every thing else.".
What makes a hit: "Catchy original sounds".
Favourite Genre: Good.
Favorite artists: Steely Dan, James Taylor, Bela Fleck, Mike Stern, Joni Mitchell.
Hero: Robben Ford.
Instruments: Guitar Vocals.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: Playing & touring extensively in Australia,.
Songs: 20.
Reviews to date: 1

335 (UK) - Age: 60 (M). Approved since 01-Feb-08
View reviews
Criteria: "To try to be objective,I listen for something with an edge and energy.Originality is important however no one is without influence s but there is only one Elvis.Hit potential is dependent on a lot more than good music,people need to hear it first.".
What makes a hit: "Music is all about communicating with people,from basic rhythms, to lyrics people can associate with.A good song always has to have those elements.A potential hit needs to flow,seamlessly,from one movement to the next and be performed with conviction.Vision is important too. Finally,people need a medium to be heard.".
Favourite Genre: Rock and Roll, Blues, Pop, .
Favorite artists: ZZ Top, Beatles, Billy Joel, John Mayall, BB King, Kinks, Oasis.
Hero: Freddie King.
Reviews to date: 205

6jase5 (USA) - Age: 36 (M). Approved since 15-Oct-07
View reviews
Criteria: "Good overall songwriting, not production quality as that is easily fixed with $$$.".
What makes a hit: "Catchy, great groove, good story and melody".
Favourite Genre: rock.
Favorite artists: led zep, the who, mutemath, muse, radiohead.
Hero: grandfather.
Reviews to date: 7

Aaronishere (UK) - Age: 29 (M). Approved since 19-Jan-08
View reviews
Criteria: "the hook, the lyrics and overall sound.".
What makes a hit: "a hook or lyric that most people can latch on to or relate their life to".
Favourite Genre: Indie.
Favorite artists: Arctic Monkeys, Hoosiers, Elbow.
Hero: Alex Turner.
Reviews to date: 8

advent22 (UK) - Age: 23 (M). Approved since 05-Aug-08
View reviews
Criteria: "How well the band work together, how well the song is arranged, and overall whether they would survive in this massive industry!".
What makes a hit:-.
Favourite Genre: Punk.
Favorite artists: The Clash, The Ramones.
Hero:-.
Reviews to date: 1

Adx (UK) - Age: 22 (M). Approved since 05-Aug-08
View reviews
Criteria: "You can remember some lyrics and tune after just one listen".
What makes a hit: "You can remember some lyrics and tune after just one listen".
Favourite Genre: Everything.
Favorite artists: Muse Prodigy.
Hero: Me.
Reviews to date: 1

Afro (Canada) - Age: 21 (M). Approved since Tuesday, August 05, 2008
View reviews
Criteria:-.
What makes a hit:-.
Favourite Genre:-.
Favorite artists:-.
Hero:-.
Reviews to date: 0

ali (UK) - Age: 45 (M). Approved since 26-Jan-08
View reviews
Criteria: "most important aspect is being honest and constructive when reviewing a song. I like to listen to the flow of the song".
What makes a hit: "Any song thats produced and marketed efficiently to a specific target audience has the chance of being a ´´hit´´ - but a good song is always a good song whether its a hit or not".
Favourite Genre: Rock punk early goth Indie.
Favorite artists: The Clash,Killing Joke, The Cult, Bauhaus, sisters of mercy, primal Scream, The stone Roses and Kasabian to name a few.
Hero: John Peel, Joe Strummer.
Instruments: Bass guitar
some rhythm and lead guitar
.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: Probably reaching the fg main show with my band The Mortal(higher Plain 143 main).
Reviews to date: 49

AllenJones (USA) - Age: 27 (M). Approved since 07-Jun-07
View reviews
Criteria: "lyrics solid beat and that almighty hook like in two from the time you heard the song your singig it cause its stuck in your head".
What makes a hit: "*hook*".
Favourite Genre: ROCK AND COUNTRY.
Favorite artists: THREE DOORS DOWN, NICKELBACK SOME OLD SCHOOL LIKE JIMMI HENDRIX LED ZEPLIN DEEP PUPRLE KISS.
Hero: SPIDERMAN.
Instruments: GUITAR/BASS.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments:-.
Songs: 100-150.
Reviews to date: 5

altotus (USA) - Age: 26 (M). Approved since 29-Jun-08
View reviews
Criteria: "not sure".
What makes a hit: "Something with a unique sound, but one that you can sing along with-- that you can´t get out of your head and it doesn´t bother you.".
Favourite Genre: Christian, Pop.
Favorite artists: ..
Hero: ..
Reviews to date: 2

amg (USA) - Age: 63 (F). Approved since 20-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "Harmony, (in voices and instaments, )good lyrics, good beat, something good to dance too. (fast and slow)".
What makes a hit: "for me it is all of the above . Hit potential is not important to me in a song IF I LIKE IT. But I do wonder WHY it did not make the hit charts.".
Favourite Genre: 50, 60´s rocknroll, music that makes me want to get out and dance. Songs that have meaningful lyrics to ME! Instramentals with alot of brass especially saxaphone and trumpets. I like a variety of music, but these are my favorites.
Favorite artists: beatles, creedence clearwater revival, los lobos, johnny cash, dean martin, jo stafford ,the old singers of the past. There are many.
Hero: mom and dad.
Reviews to date: 1

AnAukwardSilence (USA) - Age: 23 (M). N/A
View reviews
Criteria: "Content. A bad production can still carry a great song. Lyrics are most important to me, followed by pleasant instrumental play.".
What makes a hit: "Having a catchy tune mixed with honest lyrics.".
Favourite Genre: Indie Rock. Really, I love all music. I have a `piece by piece` or `artist by artist` perspective..
Favorite artists: Dashboard Confessional John Mayer Alanis Morisette The Early November I Can Make a Mess Like Nobody`s Business Bright Eyes Plain White T`s From First to Last NoFX Screeching Weasel Tim McGraw Garth Brooks Boys Like Girls The Spill Canvas Crimson Moon Dragonforce Hammerfall.
Hero: Chris Carrabba..
Instruments: Guitar Bass Drums (any percussion for any style) Vocals Some Keys..
Past Credits: EP is unreleased....
Accomplishments: Radio Play. And my upcoming 4 song EP -- my first professional release. I had a really great CD Release show for my first CD (last August) and sold out of the few copies I had of it in two shows. I have had good reviews from several labels, but I have not quite put out something to get signed -- I am hoping this will be accomplished with the upcoming album..
Songs: Upwards 100.
Reviews to date: 2

Anna (ITALY) - Age: 41 (F). Approved since 18-Jan-08
View reviews
Criteria: "Production, arrangements".
What makes a hit: "Melody, interpretation".
Favourite Genre: Electronic, Classical.
Favorite artists:-.
Hero:-.
Reviews to date: 30

Antsy (UK) - Age: 51 (M). Approved since 22-Aug-07
View reviews
Criteria: "A song has to be tight and clever. I like the lyrics to mean something andthe melodies to be bold. The arrangements have to feel fresh and surprising.".
What makes a hit: "Hit potential IS important, but the definition of ´´hit´´ may vary. A ´´hit´´ is something that sticks and gives you an aesthetic pleasure - or excitement.".
Favourite Genre: All styles really.
Favorite artists: Very broad tastes. No single artist stands out..
Hero: Again, many great models to aspire to..
Instruments: Keys, guitars, drums, woodwinds.
Past Credits: No name-dropping here, please..
Accomplishments: Around 100,000 albums sold..
Reviews to date: 216

Armageddon (USA) - Age: 46 (M). N/A
View reviews
Criteria: "strong structures and commercial potential without being cheap or cheesy. I love and appreciate real talent, without which I wouldn`t waste my time on an artist who can at best be a one-hit wonder.".
What makes a hit:-.
Favourite Genre:-.
Favorite artists:-.
Hero:-.
Past Credits: A&R Consultant, USA majors mainly.
Accomplishments: A&R Consultant, USA majors mainly.
Reviews to date: 209

ArthurMay (SPAIN) - Age: 54 (M). Approved since 04-Aug-07
View reviews
Criteria: "Several factors are key. Balance and development, musical excellence, production and inoversion, recording quality, interpretaion (under musical excellence) Dynamics. And the ability to know what, when and when not to play.".
What makes a hit: "I seperate hit from a good song firstly. In pop terms there is a tried and tested formular, hit them with the hook, and sell records, but I see an attitude chane to that. The 14-16 years old bracket no longer buys records as well you know. There is no longer a baby boom going on and the market is wide open. I worked with Mickey Most, he told me if a song stands up acapella of with just a simple itar or piano backing it`s a potential hit. There`s a lot of truth in that. Hit potential is a generalization, I can think of many hits that have broken the formular.".
Favourite Genre: I like all good quality music, I can`t seperate my favorite stye. It`s all valid to me..
Favorite artists: Beatles, Sex Pistols, Eagles, Radio Head, Eddie Cochran, Chuck Berry, Jerry Lee Lewis, Elton John, Bob Dylan, Joni Michael, Crowded House, and just about everyone who has class and quality..
Hero: Mr Bean.
Instruments: Vocal, piano, Guitar, Bass, Drums, Violin and related instruments..
Past Credits: I started my own production company working with local Bands from the region. Among my clients are Suzanna Rey, and a fellow called Diego, he was a foorball player/singer, he never paid his bills but I see he`s on Sol Music evry five minutes these days, J.
Accomplishments: Surviving since 1968. I made my first record for Pathe Marconi in France. I`ve since produced Toto Koelo, written for several artist including Tina Charles, worked in production for Redwood in London, was also professional manager for Interworld Music in the 80`s. A popular punk band leader among other projects..
Songs: Hundreads.
Reviews to date: 45

AshtonJade (SPAIN) - Age: 21 (F). Approved since 21-Apr-08
View reviews
Criteria: "A good beat, a good melody and something unique... that makes it stand out from everyother song. Vocals are very important to me I love listening to someone who can really sing and I also like hearing a voice with a unique tone to it.".
What makes a hit: "The melody if it is rememberable and catchy... and makes you feel good when you listen to it and you will want to listen to it again and again.".
Favourite Genre: I like all genres of music. It depends on my mood. .
Favorite artists: Rihanna, Micheal Buble, Justin Timberlake, The Last Goodnight, Josh Hoge and Robin Thicke..
Hero: Simon Cowell/Britney Spears.
Instruments: Vocals and I have up to Grade 4 in both Oboe and Piano. I also have Grade 7 in Music Theory..
Past Credits: I sing along the Costa del Sol, Spain and have done for the past 4 years in many bars, restaurants, a variety of charity events and private parties. I starred in a production of Joseph and the Technicolor Dreamcoat as the part of the narrator.
.
Accomplishments: Gaining Full marks for my Music Technology coursework.
Performing In a local Televised Competition Called SolStar and winning.
Completing a very personal song called Girl with a Dream and performing it live on a local radio station..
Reviews to date: 10

AstronautJeremy (USA) - Age: 27 (M). Approved since Monday, April 21, 2008
View reviews
Criteria: "Honesty. I listen for composition, texture, technicality, vocal conviction and style, and tightness.".
What makes a hit: "A hit with me would be a tight band with challenging music and great vocals with intelligent lyrics.".
Favourite Genre: Progressive Rock.
Favorite artists: Meshuggah, Opeth, Dream Theater, Dameira, Tool, Thrice, Nine Inch Nails, Killswitch Engage, Incubus.
Hero: John Petrucci.
Instruments: Guitar, Bass, Vocals, Keyboard.
Past Credits: ´´God´s Eye´´ album by Astronaut Down 2007,
´´Space Age Material´´ album by Astronaut Down 2003,
´´Propeller´´ album by Nerd Glasses Experiment 2002,
´´Ditch the Chess Club´´ album by Room 4 2001,
´´It´s Goap´´ album by Thick Air 2001,
´´Watch it Spin Around´´ album by Room 4 2000,
´´Based on the Best-Selling Novel´´ album by Room 4 1999,
´´The Persians´´ album from Waterwell Productions 2006
.
Accomplishments: Co-creating ´´God´s Eye´´ by Astronaut Down,
Co-creating ´´Space Age Material´´ by Astronaut Down, Co-writing ´´Ditch the Chess Club´´ by Room 4, Co-writing ´´Watch it Spin Around´´ by Room 4.
Reviews to date: 0

BAMcFarland (USA) - Age: 18 (M). Approved since 30-Apr-07
View reviews
Criteria: "the beat the words and the flow of the artist".
What makes a hit: "the waay the artist sounds and if i like the beat or not".
Favourite Genre: rap.
Favorite artists: tech n9ne sharod.
Hero: ty law.
Instruments: guitare.
Past Credits: none.
Accomplishments: none.
Reviews to date: 1

BC (SOUTH AFRICA) - Age: 27 (M). Approved since 15-Aug-08
View reviews
Criteria: "melody, is it catchy enough for airplay? song lenght, vocal pitching, arrangement, general playing of intruments..".
What makes a hit: "easy melody, catchy tune makes hit, hit potential is very important, more airplay means more success".
Favourite Genre: Alternative rock, acoustic .
Favorite artists:-.
Hero:-.
Instruments: Drums.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: Sound engineer for rodriquez, sound engineer for major bands in South Africa.
Reviews to date: 1

bearf28 (USA) - Age: 31 (M). Approved since Friday, August 15, 2008
View reviews
Criteria: "I like melody and musicianship. I enjoy good grooves that make me move. Interesting lyrics and themes.".
What makes a hit: "It´s important if you want to make alot of money in this business.".
Favourite Genre: I enjoy heavy music like metal, also industrial, acoustic, and rock n roll..
Favorite artists: Metallica, Alice in Chains, Tool, Fear Factory, Mudvayne, American Head Charge, Neil Young, Boston, Echobrain, etc..
Hero: Lemmy.
Instruments: Guitar, Vocals, Keys, Sax.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: Working with many musicians in multiple projects including my own band..
Reviews to date: 0

beatman (AUSTRALIA) - Age: 41 (M). Approved since 08-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "it is to find it,s value as a listener".
What makes a hit: "whant it affects you in anyway..good of cource".
Favourite Genre: elctronica.
Favorite artists:-.
Hero:-.
Reviews to date: 9

bebus (UK) - Age: 36 (F). Approved since 14-Oct-07
View reviews
Criteria: "Strong melody/hook - great vocal - lyrics are very important.".
What makes a hit: "I look for great songs - If you have found a great song - you have found a hit.".
Favourite Genre: Rock,Pop, acoustic, good melody and great vocals.
Favorite artists: Aimee Mann, Nick Kelly, Sarah Maclachlan, Jellyfish, John Foxx, Sam Brown, Sam Phillips, David Sylvian..
Hero: John Foxx, David Sylvian & Andy Sturmer.
Instruments: Guitar & Keys.
Past Credits: Member of

Mahalia, Steal & CS Drift.
Accomplishments: Tribute song on ´´Sensory Lullabies - Ultimate Tribute to Jellyfish´´... Burning Sky Records.
Reviews to date: 4

beegee (FINLAND) - Age: 27 (M). Approved since 29-Jun-08
View reviews
Criteria: "the hook".
What makes a hit: "a clear punch".
Favourite Genre: electronic.
Favorite artists: benassi.
Hero:-.
Reviews to date: 25

Beercandyman (USA) - Age: 51 (M). Approved since Sunday, June 29, 2008
View reviews
Criteria: "Be honest without being mean. Being constructive".
What makes a hit: "Good words and notes.".
Favourite Genre: Blues and Pop..
Favorite artists: Little Walter, Rolling Stones.
Hero: John Lennon.
Instruments: I play Guitar, Harmonica, and Sing.
Past Credits: Southern California Homebrewers Fest.
Accomplishments: I play in front of 1,000 people every year. My song, ´´Pale Ale is a Friend of mine´´ is played on every Homebrew Radio program..
Reviews to date: 0

benfan30 (USA) - Age: 30 (F). Approved since 03-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "the music and the lyrics.".
What makes a hit: "A hit is a song that gets a lot of plays on the radio, yes, hit potential is important in a song.
".
Favourite Genre: soft rock.
Favorite artists: Evanescence, Breaking Benajmin, etc..
Hero: my parents, God, Jesus Christ..
Reviews to date: 2

BigDeals (USA) - Age: 1929 (M). Approved since 19-Jun-08
View reviews
Criteria: "I listen for a catchy hook".
What makes a hit: "It must be catchy and have a great hook to make it a hit.".
Favourite Genre: Pop.
Favorite artists: Justin Timberlake
Michael Jackson
.
Hero:-.
Instruments: Vocals.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments:-.
Reviews to date: 2

bigjdp (USA) - Age: 29 (M). Approved since 08-Aug-08
View reviews
Criteria: "The emotion in the song.".
What makes a hit: "A ´´hit´´ is a song that EVERYONE can feel. ´´Hit potential´´ is very important.".
Favourite Genre: Hip-Hop/R&B.
Favorite artists: Jay-Z, Beanie Sigel, Usher, R. Kelly.
Hero: Fred Taylor.
Reviews to date: 1

BIGJOHN12 (USA) - Age: 41 (M). Approved since 29-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "originality uniqueness creativity".
What makes a hit: "A HIT IS IN THE EYE OF THE BEHOLDER I THINK
A PERSON THAT HAS A GOOD MESSAGE IN THIER
MUSIC CAN HAVE A HIT
".
Favourite Genre: jazz,soul,funk.
Favorite artists: lala hathaway, ojays, ella fitzgerald.
Hero: my parents.
Reviews to date: 1

Bill Brandenburgh (USA) - Age: 42 (M). Approved since 05-Oct-07
View reviews
Criteria: "Hooks/Riffs Production Quality
".
What makes a hit:-.
Favourite Genre: Classic Rock, Powerpop, Prog Rock.
Favorite artists: The Who, Led Zepppelin, Yes, ELP, Queen.
Hero:-.
Instruments: Vocals, Keyboards, Cello, Bass.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: Played 10 yrs with Glenn Phillips Band.
Reviews to date: 2

BillStevens (USA) - Age: 28 (M). Approved since 18-Oct-07
View reviews
Criteria: "I want to hear great melodies and performances".
What makes a hit: "A hit is something that´s so good that everybody gets it. Not everything on Billboard is a real hit however!".
Favourite Genre: rnb and some kinds of rock. But nny music may work if its good..
Favorite artists: babyface, aguilera, and such.
Hero: babyface.
Instruments: keys, guitar, drums.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments:-.
Reviews to date: 188

Bluesman (USA) - Age: 54 (M). Approved since Thursday, October 18, 2007
View reviews
Criteria: "I listen to see if they can make it believable, sell themselves as a produt, got to have heart and soul".
What makes a hit: "it has to be something that i can relate to on a personal level, it can`t be over engineered or computer inhanced, needs to be real".
Favourite Genre: Blues, Folk.
Favorite artists: Albert Collins, Tab Benoit, Luther Allison.
Hero: My Father.
Instruments: Guitar, Harmonica, Vocals.
Past Credits: Cindy & The Rockets
Guitar Curtis & The Blues Imposters
,Alan Hall Blues Band.
Accomplishments: Jam session host for 4 years, dedicated to the preservation of old school blues, promotor of new and young talents.
Reviews to date: 0

BobbyBass (UK) - Age: 33 (M). Approved since 04-Mar-08
View reviews
Criteria: "Song writing and production are the most important aspect to me and bass playing".
What makes a hit: "A song should be catchy have a hook and not be to long this is not important to me but is to radio stations and Jo Bloggs.".
Favourite Genre: All music styles.
Favorite artists: Radiohead
Simon and Garfunkle
Bee Gees
Paul weller
Sex pistols
Super fury animals and everyone in between.
Hero: Dad.
Instruments: Bass and vocals.
Past Credits: none.
Accomplishments: I´m just a bedroom player.
Reviews to date: 6

BobPattersonakaBogey (USA) - Age: 49 (M). Approved since 24-May-08
View reviews
Criteria: "NA".
What makes a hit: "NA".
Favourite Genre: Blues, Classic and Southern Country Rock.
Favorite artists: To many to name.
Hero: My Saviour, The Lord Jesus Christ.
Instruments: Guitar, Vocals.
Past Credits: NA.
Accomplishments: Friends that are made thru my music..
Reviews to date: 1

Bonnie615 (USA) - Age: 36 (F). Approved since Saturday, May 24, 2008
View reviews
Criteria: "I judge a song by how it makes me feel... if I feel it ends too soon and if I want to hear it again and again. I cannot get enough of a song I love.".
What makes a hit: "If you see everyone around listening, not ignoring, the song and everything from above.".
Favourite Genre: Alternative
Pop
R & B
.
Favorite artists: Sunset Slim!.
Hero:-.
Instruments:-.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments:-.
Reviews to date: 0

Boots (UK) - Age: 31 (F). Approved since 20-Feb-08
View reviews
Criteria: "whatever grabs me".
What makes a hit: "If i knew the secret of what makes a hit I´d be a millionaire".
Favourite Genre: I dont have a favourite..
Favorite artists: Too many to mention..
Hero: no one.
Reviews to date: 6

bori (USA) - Age: 29 (F). Approved since 19-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "The most important aspect of reviewing a song, to me, is objectivity. I listen for a song that makes me dance, makes me cry, MAKES me do anything...".
What makes a hit: "A hit song to me will not leave your head easily. If I hear a song early in the day, and later in the day I find myself singing it...that´s a hit.".
Favourite Genre: All types of Pop, Latin, and Reggae music.
Favorite artists: Michael Jackson, Billie Holiday, Celine Dion, Biggie Smalls, Jay-Z, and Mariah Carey to name a few....
Hero: My mother.
Reviews to date: 2

boynamedsue (AFGHANISTAN) - Age: 28 (M). Approved since 14-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "anything memorable. songs should stick with you, have a chorus that you can sing-along too.".
What makes a hit: "musicianship and hooky tracks.".
Favourite Genre: Rock.
Favorite artists: AC/DC
Led Zeppelin
Social Distortion
My Chemical Romance.
Hero: George Carlin.
Reviews to date: 2

bozzwell (USA) - Age: 37 (M). Approved since 16-Jun-08
View reviews
Criteria: "originality, lyrics, hooks".
What makes a hit: "What others are listening to. Hit potential is important for marketing, not for listening.".
Favourite Genre: pop-rock, punk-rock, indie.
Favorite artists: The Smiths.
Hero:-.
Reviews to date: 1

bparris (USA) - Age: 30 (M). Approved since 23-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "Just like many others, I try to be objective...I try to look at things from a crossover perspective. ".
What makes a hit: "A hit song is a song that excites me! I still like to get excited about music! Hearing a song that I can groove to or find myself singing all day is great...hearing a song that makes me say ´´WHOA!´´...that´s the ultimate.".
Favourite Genre: Pop.
Favorite artists: Prince, Michael Jackson, Peter Gabriel, Sting, Jay-Z, The Beatles, James Brown.
Hero: There are many....
Reviews to date: 2

Brenda (USA) - Age: 41 (F). Approved since 14-Aug-08
View reviews
Criteria: "heart / soul".
What makes a hit: "If it touches a woman or speaks for a man hit potential is important".
Favourite Genre: all.
Favorite artists:-.
Hero:-.
Reviews to date: 7

browneyes (USA) - Age: 38 (F). Approved since 04-Jun-08
View reviews
Criteria: "Lyrics, music, vocals. I think you have to listen to a song at leas t2 or 3 times to really take it in.".
What makes a hit: "I don´t know, because a lot of songs that are hits on the radio now, i don´t like".
Favourite Genre: Pop/Rock, R&B, Classical.
Favorite artists: u2,Aerosmith, Amel Larriuex, Goapele, Beatles, BobMarley.
Hero: Mom.
Reviews to date: 2

Butterflies are Shit (UK) - Age: 37 (M). Approved since 28-Jan-08
View reviews
Criteria: "I´ve always held that the most important aspect of appreciating anything - whether as a reviewer or a listener (and ultimately, isn´t the former just a more egocentric version of the latter?) is understanding its theme/point. I´m always impressed by a song that expresses something beyond the desire to fill up 4-5 minutes on a CD, and its elements combine to express it coherently.".
What makes a hit: "Far from it. A ´´hit´´ is something that is designed to make morons dance at weddings without shame, and the less encouragement people like that recieve, the better for all concerned.".
Favourite Genre: Anything with conviction and good writing, though if one must travel under a flag of (in)convenience, I´d opt for rock/country/blues/folk.
Favorite artists: Tom Waits, The Dead Kennedys, The Ramones, CrackTown, Muddy Waters, Grateful Dead, Status Quo ... is anybody even reading this far in?.
Hero: John Henry.
Reviews to date: 4

candygramformongo (USA) - Age: 34 (M). Approved since Monday, January 28, 2008
View reviews
Criteria: "hooks.".
What makes a hit: "hooks.".
Favourite Genre: Rock.
Favorite artists: Led Zeppelin, AC/DC, Social Distortion.
Hero: George Carlin.
Instruments: Drums.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: I´ve placed songs on TV shows including BATTLESTAR GALACTICA on the Sci-Fi Channel and the Fox sitcom, UNHITCHED, by The Farrelly Bros (There´s Something About Mary, Dumb & Dumber)..
Reviews to date: 0

Carnell (USA) - Age: 27 (M). Approved since 25-Jul-07
View reviews
Criteria: "lyrics and lack of repetition.".
What makes a hit: "hit potential is important, and a hit is simply whether or not the production quality is up to par, along with the songs catchiness.".
Favourite Genre: Acoustic indie folk.
Favorite artists: Damien Rice, Dave Matthews, Simon and Garfunkel.
Hero: Phillip Pullman.
Instruments: guitar and vocals.
Past Credits: recorded in studio with small independent musicians.
Accomplishments: recorded in studio with small indepen dent musicians.
Songs: 0.
Reviews to date: 2

catherine (UK) - Age: 32 (F). Approved since 07-Dec-07
View reviews
Criteria: "being honest to your own perception..see im not a proffesional i just love music so i can share my opinion thats all really but as far as what i listen for in a song it has to start with the lyrics for me they are most important if it has soul and you can hear it has come from the heart..".
What makes a hit: "the lyrics..something others can sing along to naturally:)".
Favourite Genre:
soft rock.........
Favorite artists: my beautiful daughter.sheryl crow.snow patrol.my taylor.blondie.white stripes.jackass.serendipity.greenday. rolling stones.kt tunstall.kooks.talking heads.red hot chili peppers.winehouse.bob dylan.strokes.foo fighters.james.listening to unsigned..gwen stefani.. fast show.streets. dido.killers.egg on toast with brown sauce.razorlight.kasabian. killers..laughing.zutons.cranberries the clash.cuddles..without a paddle´funny as.fruit pastels(lots of em).the sunshine.:)writing a new song.cheese.
Hero: my daughter.
Reviews to date: 1

Chilly01 (USA) - Age: 33 (M). Approved since 30-Sep-07
View reviews
Criteria: "I listen for a good, strong voice.".
What makes a hit: "That depends, alot of things I wouldn´t consider to be a hit, make it.".
Favourite Genre: I enjoy all styles of music.
Favorite artists: Mint Condition.
Hero: My Uncle.
Reviews to date: 15

Chocolatebubbles (USA) - Age: 27 (F). Approved since 10-Jan-08
View reviews
Criteria: "I think that people should give all genres a chance, open those ears and you may discover some amazing music out there. ".
What makes a hit: "A know a hit in my heart when I get goosebumps and want to put it on repeat. ".
Favourite Genre: Rock, Jazz, Folk, Pop, Punk and some country.
Favorite artists: No particular favorite artist..
Hero: People who follow their dreams, no matter how far off they may sound to others!.
Reviews to date: 577

Citizen UK (UK) - Age: 45 (M). Approved since Thursday, January 10, 2008
View reviews
Criteria: "A hook".
What makes a hit: "A hook and a riff".
Favourite Genre: Punk Rock,Power Pop,Power Electronics.
Favorite artists: Angry Samoans,Art Attacks,GG Allin..
Hero:-.
Instruments: Guitar,Bass,Vocals.
Past Credits: Deans Bedroom,Doctor Shitt,Chainsaw Injectors..
Accomplishments: Freedom.
Reviews to date: 0

Cjay (USA) - Age: 20 (M). Approved since 20-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "good sound , good quality good vocals".
What makes a hit: "any song that transport you to a better place".
Favourite Genre: Regggaeton.
Favorite artists: Wisin Y Yandel.
Hero: Spiderman.
Instruments: guitar and vocals.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: recorded an album to clome out soon.
Reviews to date: 14

CJDrumm (USA) - Age: 56 (M). Approved since 04-Jun-07
View reviews
Criteria: "I am a ``lyrics hound``. Songs are ``stories with music``, so I`d better be able to understand what the artist is saying, enunciation, projection, wording rhythms, etc., or I am not listening for long.".
What makes a hit: "This is a tad vaque to be answered in a small box. It really depends on genre, I would think. Rock doesn`t seem to need deep, thought evoking lyrics as much as a ballad would, and a ballad does not need a backbone snapping bass line a nd drum beat to get it`s message across.".
Favourite Genre: BLUES.
Favorite artists: Eric Capton, BB King.
Hero: My daughter ,Emily.
Instruments: vocals, guitar.
Past Credits: credits? In 1989, I was hired out of a bar gig to portray a country singer in a large gala in HONG KONG. I spent 4 days in HK, treated like I was Elvis Presley by my hosts. I haven`t made it a habit of entering contests in my musical career, was busy rais.
Accomplishments: biggest accompl ishment, hmm, that I am able to continue playing music. I`ve had some issues that made continuing doubtful. I think I may have overcome these issues..
Songs: 100?.
Reviews to date: 8

clam (UK) - Age: 47 (M). Approved since Monday, June 04, 2007
View reviews
Criteria: "Musicality, euphonics, melody, beauty, story, credibility, work.".
What makes a hit: "Musicality, euphonics, melody, beauty, story, credibility, work!
Yes it is
".
Favourite Genre: Acoustic guitar based songwriters, players. Irish/American roots. .
Favorite artists: Dan Crary, Doc Watson, Clarance White, Floyd, Neil Young, Eric Clapton.
Hero: Eric Clapton.
Instruments: Flatpick acoustic guitar, vocals.
Past Credits: The Choirboys, The OvertheHillbillies, The Gully Jumpers, Joff Lowson..
Accomplishments: I played with the Gully Jumpers, UKs hottest bluegrass band of the 90s. I ´ve never stopped learning and developing my playing technique and style..
Reviews to date: 0

claysmom (USA) - Age: 30 (F). Approved since 30-Jun-08
View reviews
Criteria: "Feelings and flow".
What makes a hit: "A hit is a song that has a lot of potential and makes sense. I don´t believe it´s always important to a song.".
Favourite Genre: Indie...pop.
Favorite artists: Jake Niemi, Taylor Swift, OneRepublic.
Hero: my son.
Reviews to date: 2

Corliss (USA) - Age: 60 (F). Approved since 07-Oct-07
View reviews
Criteria: "The lyrics and the beat. Do they flow together. Also, you should actually know how to sing.".
What makes a hit: "hit potential is important".
Favourite Genre: R&B.
Favorite artists: Sade.
Hero: I am my own hero.
Reviews to date: 6

Cowbell (UK) - Age: 33 (F). Approved since 16-Jan-08
View reviews
Criteria: "The most important thing when reviewing is honesty. The ´reviewee´ can either sulk about it or he/she can get better. It´s a choice.".
What makes a hit: "A hit comes outta you when you least expect it and ultimately, from having written a hundred or more ´flops´ first!".
Favourite Genre: Pop-Rock-R&B.
Favorite artists: It´s a long list ... a very long list..
Hero: Mom & Dad, of course.
Instruments: Piano, saxophone, drums, voice, bass guitar.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: Realizing that the music business can be aload of shite.
Reviews to date: 65

cpc_esq (USA) - Age: 56 (M). Approved since Wednesday, January 16, 2008
View reviews
Criteria: "Good underlayment, especially in rock music. It has to have a good bass line, musically, and a story or message, lyrically, to attract my attention.".
What makes a hit: "A hit is a song that reaches and appeals to its target audience. The term ´´hit´´ is relative in that sense. If it is interpreted to mean ´´a song that appeals widely´´ and therefore will sell well it is not as important as whether it is a good song.".
Favourite Genre: Classics / classic rock / easy listening / country.
Favorite artists: Beach Boys, Chicago, Bach, Beethoven, George Gershwin.
Hero: My dad.
Instruments: Clarinet, saxophone, guitar, banjo, vocals, keyboards (piano).
Past Credits: None.
Accomplishments: Performed a shortened version (8 min) of Rhapsody in Blue.
Reviews to date: 0

crankyboy (USA) - Age: 47 (M). Approved since 04-Apr-08
View reviews
Criteria: "originality".
What makes a hit: "lyrical content, good melody and a hook.
hit potential is not so important to me, i am not out signing bands to contracts.
".
Favourite Genre: rock and blues.
Favorite artists: rush. led zepplin, pink floyd, stevie ray vaughn,.
Hero: stevie.
Instruments: guitar.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: playing as a sit in studio player at a local studio.
Reviews to date: 7

CrudeBastard (USA) - Age: 37 (M). Approved since 15-Mar-08
View reviews
Criteria: "A song needs to make sense to the people it is aimed at. Lyrically, melodically, structurally. But it also needs to challenge and involve the listener. It needs to create a feeling of familiarity on one hand and surprise on the other. And it needs to sound like LOVE has gone into it.".
What makes a hit: "A hit - if you understand the true intention behind that word - is a song which connects with its listeners. Today´s media fabricate hits by rotating them even if people don´t request them. Even if you´re a jazz writer, you want your song to ´´hit´´ your audience. So yes - having a hit is very important because it proves to you that you can write music well in your chosen style.".
Favourite Genre: Anything with soul in it.
Favorite artists: Many: from Beatles to Timbaland, from Dizzy Gillespie to Jean-Michel Jarre. Anything that´s got soul..
Hero: Dalai Lama.
Instruments: Drums, keys, guitars.
Past Credits: Was signed with EMI and later Warner. Released many records where I was sideman (session player). Other artists cover some of my songs now and then..
Accomplishments: A few minor hits, reached Billboard Hot100 more than once.
Reviews to date: 68

Crunch (USA) - Age: 26 (F). Approved since 23-Aug-07
View reviews
Criteria: "I listen for sincerity in the voice as well as a measure of skill -- I love a singer that has range, good vocal agility & a unique tone. I also love to hear a ´´ring´´ in the voice. I also listen closely to lyrics and like anything that shows heart and modern poetry skills.".
What makes a hit: "A hit song gets you in the first 15 seconds on the first listen and makes you want to hear it again and again and again. Clever creativity used inside the strict Verse-Chrous-Verse-Chorus-Bridge-Chorus formula works everytime.".
Favourite Genre:-.
Favorite artists: From The Eagles to Boyz II Men to Limp Bizkit to Alicia Keys.
Hero: Frank Zappa.
Past Credits: Getting signed and living the dream..
Accomplishments: Lasting friendships that transcend the music business. One Grammy nomination so far & a dozen more to go!..
Reviews to date: 131

CrystalHunter (USA) - Age: 2008 (F). N/A
View reviews
Criteria: "na".
What makes a hit: "na".
Favourite Genre: r&B.
Favorite artists:-.
Hero:-.
Reviews to date: 2

csl81love (USA) - Age: 34 (F). Approved since 30-Jun-08
View reviews
Criteria: "vocals, lyrics".
What makes a hit: "a song that grabs me right away".
Favourite Genre: all music.
Favorite artists: John Meyer, U2, Dave Matthews band.
Hero: anyone who does anything to help someone else.
Reviews to date: 2

CW (USA) - Age: 30 (M). N/A
View reviews
Criteria: "A memorable line, something that sticks with you after you hear it.".
What makes a hit: "Catchy riffs and licks, as well as a great melody.".
Favourite Genre: Rock.
Favorite artists: Breaking Benjamin, 10 Years, Tool.
Hero: Jesus.
Instruments: Guitar.
Past Credits:-.
Accomplishments: well, not much unfortunately. I played in a band in high school and we had a few club gigs..
Songs: 48.
Reviews to date: 77

dan (UK) - Age: 23 (M). Approved since 28-Jul-08
View reviews
Criteria: "good hook and a catchy chorus".
What makes a hit: "something universal and that appeals to alot of people".
Favourite Genre: a bit of everything.
Favorite artists: too many to go into.
Hero: everyone who influences me.
Reviews to date: 1

dangerbird (USA) - Age: 48 (M). Approved since 23-Jan-08
View reviews
Criteria: "Simplicity, Strong vocals,
Writing.
".
What makes a hit: "Not important, a Hit will find its way
to the top in itself. It must have all of the right combinations of heart and soul.
".